Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Home arrow Shopping Guide arrow Voice over IP (Voip) Buying Guide
Voice over IP (Voip) Buying Guide

SunRocket, Inc.VoIP has been garnering much ink over the last year and is currently one of the hottest segments of the industry. The technology allows voice traffic to be routed over the Internet or corporate intranet--which means virtually no billing at all for some long-distance calls and just local charges for others. More important, is that it all happens behind the scenes and is transparent to the user. Simply pick up the phone and dial! The products available today can do this with no apparent loss in quality, and companies are jumping on board to save bundles of cash.

VOIP Services Compare

GuideBuy.com VOIP team continually researches, tests and reviews all VoIP services. Below we have selected the best providers and laid out all the information we believe you need to make an informed buying decision. All these services provide quality local and long distance home phone service over a high speed internet connection using your current phone, will save most people hundreds of dollars a year, and include free in-network calling, caller id showing caller's name, call waiting, and many more features like online message playback that traditional phone service can't offer. Just click on the service you think is right for you to find out more or place an order. If you are interested in VoIP services that let you make calls from your computer, you should take a look at Skype .
 

 

ProviderPlans/
Monthly Cost
Setup FeesCancellation Fees$ Back GuaranteePromotions*Countries IncludedOverall Rating
SunRocket, Inc.

SunRocket
Unlimited: $16.58 w/ yr. prepay or $24.95; 200 minutes: $9.95$39.95 equipment fee waived with annual plan$0; Will return prepay if you cancel before 1 year31 daysFree GE cordless phone & no equipment fee w/ yr. plan, free extra phone #, $3 int'l credit/mo. with unlimited plansUSA, Canada, Puerto Rico; also have int'l plans5 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: With its free GE cordless phone promotion, quality service, rock bottom prices and no extra fee pledge (most VoIP providers charge activation fees, taxes, cancellation fees, etc.), we believe SunRocket offers the best overall value in VoIP. To get the $16.58 monthly rate for unlimited minutes, you must prepay for the entire year, which is $199, but you can cancel any time and get a refund for your unused months. Since SunRocket includes all taxes and surcharges in their price, you pay the $199 up front and then are able to make all the local and long distance calls you want for the next 12 months without having to pay a single penny more. Most other companies charge taxes and surcharges on top of their listed rates. SunRocket also throws in $3 free international calling per month, a free extra phone number and two free directory assistance calls per month with their unlimited plans. SunRocket is currently waiving their $39.95 equipment fee when you sign up for the $199 annual plan, making it an even better deal. They also offer a $9.95 per month plan for 200 minutes that is a nice value for less frequent callers but the free phone promotion does not apply. SunRocket also offers two compelling international plans, one offering unlimited calling to 41 countries and another offering limited calling.


EarthLink
Unlimited:  $24.95; 200 minutes: $14.95FREE activation for Unlimited Plan. $29.95 for Basic Plan.$50 for unreturned or non-working equipment upon cancellation.30 daysFREE activation for Unlimited PlanUSA, Canada, Puerto Rico; also have int'l plans4 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: Earthlink VoIP service (known as trueVoice), is not the cheapest VoIP provider but does offer competitive pricing. A possible drawback is the lack of some of the advanced and free included features some other well known VoIP service such as SunRocket offer. A plus for choosing trueVoice is their award-winning reputation for outstanding customer service.
VOIP - Internet Telephone Service

Voip.com

Unlimited: $16.95 w/ year prepay or $19.95; 600 minutes: $14.95$29.95 Activation; $9.95 s&h for adapter$39.95 if cancel after 30 days but before 1 year30 daysFirst month free with unlimited monthly planUSA, Canada, Puerto Rico4 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: Voip.com offers a great selection of inexpensive plans. Their year prepay unlimited plan for $203.40 is about the same price as SunRocket (although Voip.com charges activation fees and is not as flexible with cancellation) and their monthly unlimited plan for $19.95 is as cheap as you will find for a pay-as-you-go plan, especially when you include their current first month free promotion for this plan. Their 600 minute plan for $14.95 is also as cheap as you will find for that many minutes. Voip.com has two other main differentiators from the competition. First, their international rates are the cheapest we have found to most countries. Second, they boast an impressive feature set that can almost all be managed online. Overall, Voip.com offers a strong value proposition with something for everyone. We like their monthly unlimited plan and cheap international rates the best.
Click Here

Vonage

Vonage Canada
Unlimited: $24.99; 500 minutes: $14.99$29.99 Activation; $9.95 s&h$39.99 if cancel after 30 days but before 1 year30 days if not exceeded 250 mins.1st month free for unlimited plan; Free adapterUSA, Canada, Puerto Rico, Italy, France, Spain, UK, Ireland5 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: Vonage is not the cheapest VoIP service, but our testing and research has shown that it is the best. Vonage has invested the most time and money in building its network and in acquiring new customers (it has the most customers of any VoIP provider and recently completed an IPO). As a result, Vonage provides the highest quality service of any of our recommended providers and is the best choice for those who need or want superior call quality and reliability. At $24.95 per month and your first month free for their unlimited plan, Vonage is still priced to save most people hundreds of dollars a year compared to traditional phone service. Vonage recently made their service an even better value by including calls to Italy, France, Spain, UK and Ireland for free in their Unlimited plans, making it a fantastic value for frequent callers to those countries.
ProviderPlans/
Monthly Cost
Setup FeesCancellation Fees$ Back GuaranteePromotions*Countries IncludedOverall Rating
Internet Phone Service

ViaTalk
Unlimited: $15.95 - 22.95; 500 mins.: $9.95 - $14.95; Depends on commitment$29.95 Activation; $9.95 s&h for adapter (waived w/ 1 year commitment)$0 if no commitment, otherwise 50% of remaining commitment14 days, but activation, shipping are not refunded3 months free w/ 1 yr. plan and 6 months free w/ 6 yr. plan; free adapter on any unlimited planUSA, Canada4 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: ViaTalk is rivaling SunRocket's great deal by offering a one year plan at $19.95 per month ($239.40 upfront) and a two year plan at $15.95 per month ($382.80 upront = $191.40 per year). ViaTalk offers an added value of giving you the first 3 months free for the year commitment and six months free for the 2 year commitment. Keep in mind, however, that it is not quite as flexible as SunRocket because if you cancel after the 14 day guarantee period you only get half of your unused balance back (you of course do get the full balance back if you cancel during the 14-day money-back guarantee period), ViaTalk charges a $29.95 activation fee, and they don't offer the free phone. ViaTalk offers several different plans and time commitments, so you have a lot of flexibility to choose what's right for you. In addition to price and service, ViaTalk tries to differentiate itself by offering a U.S.-based customer service team that is available 24/7. We have found that they do, indeed, provide excellent customer service. Bottom line - if you are willing to commit to a year or more, you can't beat ViaTalk's value.
Lingo

Lingo
Unlimited: $21.95; 500 minutes: $14.95$29.95 Activation; $9.95 s&h$39.95 but waived if you return adapter within 14 days30 days1st month free; free adapterUSA, Canada, P.R., Western Europe; also have plans for Mexico, Asia, & more3 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: Lingo is a great all-around value but is a particularly good choice for those that want to call internationally often. Lingo is the only leading provider whose standard plan includes calls to Western Europe (although Vonage recently included calls to several Western European countries). So you can pay just $21.95 per month to call anyone in not only the U.S., Canada and Puerto Rico all you want, but also anyone in Western Europe. They also have very cheap plans for calling Mexico, Asia and many more countries and regions. Even if you never or rarely call internationally, Lingo's price, functionality and reliability make it a great choice.
8x8, Inc.

8x8, Inc.

Unlimited: $16.58 w/ year prepay or $19.99; Unlimited Global: $49.99$29.99 Activation; $12.95 s&h for adapter$59 fee if cancel after 30 days but before 1 year for monthly plans; $0 for year plan but no refund30 daysFree adapter; Free Uniden phone system with year planUSA, Canada; also have international plan to 40 countries3 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: Packet8, one of the early players in VoIP, offers another great value. They offer both a great value monthly $19.99 unlimited plan and a $199 annual unlimited plan with free phone system promotion which rivals SunRocket's. If you don't want to commit to a year or pay $199 upfront, Packet8's $19.99 per month ($29.99 activation fee) unlimited plan is hard to beat. Their $199 annual plan is similar to SunRocket's with a few caveats: they charge a $29.99 activation fee, there is no prorated refund if you cancel after the 30 day trial period, you must send in a rebate form to get the phone (you also have to pay a $99 fee if you get the free phone but cancel before the year term is over) and there are additional taxes. All that being said, the free phone system is more advanced than the one SunRocket offers. For frequent international callers, Packet8 offers a great value unlimited calling plan that includes calls to 40 different countries. Packet8 also offers another feature none of the competitors do: video phones and video calling plans. These are very cool devices that Packet8 will sell you at a discount when you subscribe to one of their plans. There is a lot to like about Packet8.


Verizon
Unlimited: $24.95; 500 minutes: $19.95$0 Activation if ordered online; $8 s&h for adapter; you must supply router$39.95 fee if cancel after 30 days but before 1 year30 daysFree Activation; Free AdapterUSA, Canada, Puerto Rico3 out of 5 stars
Guidebuy Opinion: Verizon offers one of the most reliable, high quality services (on par with Vonage) and has recently reduced its price to make it very competitive with other premium services like Vonage. If you currently subscribe to Verizon DSL, we would recommend you strongly consider Verizon VoIP. Even if you don't, we recommend you consider Verizon if you need superior call quality and reliability. Verizon VoIP is good for Verizon DSL customers because of the convenience of working with just one company on both their internet and VoIP services. Keep in mind that Verizon requires you to supply your own router to use this service.

* Guidebuy.com has secured many of these promotions exclusively for its users. Only valid if you access the provider’s site through this site.

 What is Voip?

Voice over IP is exactly what its name suggests. It is voice communication that is transmitted over an Internet Protocol (IP) service.

VoIP is seen as a disruptive technology. For a century, people have been happy to use the plain old telephone system (POTS) to make calls. When POTS calls are made, a circuit opens between the two callers. No matter how long they speak, or whether there are quiet periods in the conversation, that circuit remains open between the caller and receiver. Importantly, the further a caller is from a receiver, the dearer the call cost because telcos must lease a longer line for that call to take place.

VoIP changes this model. Now a call, just like an audio file or image file, can be broken up into packets of data and sent over an IP network. The catch with this is packets might not always travel the same path to get to their intended destination. So the continual challenge for a VoIP service provider is that these packets arrive quickly and as one voice stream when they get to the other end. Any hiccups along this path and your conversation literally makes no sense.

To get VoIP in your home or office all you need is a Broadband connection to the Internet, a subscription to a VoIP service provider and a client -- an analog telephone adaptor (ATA), IP Phone or "soft phone".

How does a VoIP call work?

So how does VoIP work? VoIP is largely dependent on a protocol called SIP (Session Initiation Protocol). The idea behind SIP is to provide a simple, lightweight means for creating and ending connections for real-time interactive communications over IP networks -- mainly for voice, but also for videoconferencing, chat, gaming or even application sharing. In other words, the protocol initiates call setup, routing, authentication and other communication features to endpoints within an IP domain.

VoIP is quite similar to e-mail. That is, you have the Internet, a server and a client. If users want to check their e-mail they would have to register with their e-mail server and download mail from that server. If they send an e-mail that also goes via that mail server. Nor do users have to be tied to one location -- they can send/receive mail while travelling. As long as they can connect to the Internet, they can use the service.

VoIP is exactly like that. There is a server, in this case a SIP proxy server or a softswitch. These are both the same -- software applications running on general purpose computing. In the first instance, the client (ATA, IP phone or soft phone) will register with a user's SIP server. So, from then on, when a caller picks up the phone to make a phone call, because the ATA has a current registration, there will be dial tone.

This works because the first thing an ATA does when it boots up is get a DHCP address so it has an address on the Internet, and then the DHCP server points to a DNS server on the Internet and it will use that to resolve this unique server and it will register with the service provider to say "hey, I am alive".

As a plug-and-play experience, this whole DHCP event is important. With many ATAs on the market today, users do not need a computer to make it work. All that is required is for the ATA to be powered up from the wall and plugged into a phone.

At the boot-up process, the ATA sends a SIP message (an invite) to the SIP register (softswitch) which is maintained by a user's VoIP service provider. The softswitch says "OK". From then on, there is a two-way communication which happens every 60 seconds, in much the same way as a heartbeat. The softswitch does a lot. It is constantly listening to thousands of people, even if they are not making calls.

VoIP service providers charge by the minute. Ensuring a call is routed efficiently and cheaply also lies with the softswitch.

Once the softswitch determines where the subscriber is, it does a thing called Least Cost Routing (LCR). It works out the least-cost path to get to its endpoint by using algorithms inside the softswitch and by provisioning. Provisioning is the process of entering subscriber information into the softswitch. This is used by the LCR algorithms, so really it's the softswitch's knowledge of the network that allows it to do LCR. For example, if someone dials Europe from a Sydney suburb, it will state the best path to that final destination. All of this is transparent to the end user.

Once the softswitch finds the least cost and sends it on to the gateway (also owned by the VoIP service provider), that gateway will do an IP to TDM (Time Division Multiplexing is the language of the POTS) conversion. It will then send it on to the PSTN via a protocol called SS7, which is the signaling system for the PSTN. In other words, SS7 is the language which telcos use to talk to each other. Once in the PSTN "cloud" it will eventually be routed to a phone number and that phone will then ring.

What is QoS?

The key factor inhibiting the growth of VoIP is Quality of Service (QoS). In a nutshell, QoS is how voice traffic is given priority over other data traffic such as e-mail, JPEGs or MP3s that traverse a network.

QoS is a very complex issue. No one provider has it right. It currently works more by luck than by good design because service providers rely on all these Internet "clouds", which are public, to deliver their services. And there is no QoS on public networks because there are no cost benefits to the private network providers to implement it. Why would an ISP implement QoS when it has its competitors traversing its network?

But quality will come down to some key areas:

• The last mile -- the link between your home and ISP

• The ISP access to the network core

• The core segment

The last mile

The last mile is where users will encounter the most probable congestion point. The reason is that this where you have the narrowest "pipe". Users may have a 256/64Kbps subscription, so if they send or receive large files it is very easy to fill that pipe with non-voice data.

The easiest way to implement QoS for a residential line is for users to use the Internet exclusively for phoning when making a call and not do any other form of Internet surfing during the call. But that is not very practical and can be difficult if the Internet connection is shared among many users in a home or small business environment.

A way to get around this is to get a modem which has in built QoS. The way a modem implements QoS is by identifying voice and giving it priority. Right now only a few of the modems on the market do this, and configuring them can be a challenge if you are not technically minded. This, of course, will change over time.

Access layer to ISP

The end user has no control at the access layer (ISP) from the ISP to the core of Internet traffic which is shared by hundreds of people. Presently, ISPs are not providing voice-aware QoS. However, what you will start seeing is ISPs offering voice to their DSL customers, with their big differentiator being "if you buy voice and data I will give you QoS".

The core

In the core of a network there is no QoS. However, QoS is not so much a problem here because the pipes are significantly bigger. In the core, a voice packet is in there with e-mail, MP3, JPEGs, TIFFs, PowerPoint files and so forth. The thing voice has going for it is that voice packets are small. So chances are, routers in the core will drop MP3s and e-mails before voice. This way the voice call experiences no latency and gets to the receiver as fast as possible.

What hardware do I need?

The Analog Telephone Adaptor

An analog telephone adapter, or ATA (also referred to as a media terminal adaptor or broadband phone adaptor), allows you to enable an ordinary telephone, including your cordless, to make VoIP calls. All you need to do is plug your analog phone into the ATA, then take your cable from the Internet port of the ATA and plug that into a spare Ethernet port on your ADSL or cable router. If you don't have a spare port you will need a switch to provide a spare Ethernet port.

Current ATA devices will set you back between $145 and $210, depending on their capabilities.

An ATA may sound like a modem, but in fact there is quite a bit of difference in the hardware technology. An ATA is specifically designed to deal with the voice traffic and not data traffic. It takes the analog human voice and converts that to an IP packet with the use of the compression codec, then sends that over the Internet.

There are several features to look out for in ATAs:

Codec: VoIP devices, including the ATA, use codecs to compress outgoing and decompress incoming voice. The codecs in an ATA receive the data and break it into small files, or packets, for sending and receiving across the IP network. There are hundreds of codecs which can be used for VoIP and as a result the quality levels differ with each one used.

The G.711 is the codec that the PSTN (Public Switched Telephone Network) uses. It is quite large for travel across the Internet, enabling 64Kbps of voice. G.729, for example, compresses voice down to 8Kbps or 20Kbps when the packet header is factored in. This packet works out to be a quarter the size, yet still maintains a high quality, and is therefore ideal for sending over an IP network. G.729 is the most commonly deployed codec in Australia.

(See table at bottom of page).

CPU performance: An ATA might say it supports a bunch of codecs (G.711, G.729 or G.722). But if one codec is more CPU intensive than the other, it needs more MIPS (millions of instructions per second) to run it. Therefore a more powerful ATA will provide better voice quality as it compresses and processes that codec a lot better than a modem with less power.

Connectivity: USB or Ethernet. Ethernet is best because it gives users the versatility of plugging in multiple devices. Whereas, if the connection was a USB ATA it would need to go via a PC.

IP Phones

IP Phones look pretty much the same as normal analog phones. The main difference here is that they are digital, and have an inbuilt ATA. Additionally, rather than having the standard RJ-11 phone connectors, IP phones use an RJ-45.

An IP phone is ideal for businesses, where Ethernet network ports are distributed around the office space. All that is required is for the user to plug the phone straight into an Ethernet port and away they go.

Broadband modems

Assuming users already have broadband, the type of modem they have is important.

A home or office modem should be Network Address Translation (NAT)-enabled. NAT is a protocol used by a device such as a firewall, router or computer, and provides a mapping between internal IP addresses and public IP addresses in real time. The modem may be NAT-enabled, with a DHCP server in it (Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol is for assigning dynamic IP addresses to devices on a network). In most cases, when the ATA is plugged in, it will boot up and automatically seek out the softswitch of the service provider to which it is connected. More on softswitches later, but for now it is important to note that the softswitch is owned by the VoIP service provider and will direct phone calls to where they are supposed to be going.

If users have an old broadband account, it is likely that their modem may not be up to scratch for voice delivery.

Users must look for these requirements in a modem:

It must terminate L2TP or PPTP: Some ISPs have a point-to-point session used for authentication. If a point-to-point session goes from user's ISP to the software on their PC, they are in trouble. This is because as soon as they plug in their ATA, their ISP is going to see the packets coming from their ATA and say "you are not authenticated". If the modem authenticates, then everything behind it will get through. Some of the older and cheaper modems don't do L2TP because of additional cost.

Ethernet on the modem: USB is inferior to Ethernet because it means the modem needs to be connected to the PC to talk. In this case, users would be limited to a soft phone.

CPU power: Modems are CPU based. A slow CPU means it can only do so many packets per second. A VoIP phone call transmits at 100 packets per second (50 packets per second each way). That is the sort of performance that every phone call is going to require of a modem (and ATA). Therefore a modem must be able to handle that traffic.

Soft Phones

Soft phones, as their name suggests, are not hardware devices. The purely software services, such as FreshTel, Skype or BroadBand Phone require users to install small software applications, or clients, on their PC to run the service. In this case, users need to connect a USB/FireWire handset or microphone headset to a PC to talk.

The key point to note here is that users need to have their PC turned on at all times to make and receive calls.

CodecsDescriptionSampling Rate (Khz)Bitrate (Kbps)MOS
G.711Pulse Code Modulation (PCM)8643.65
G.7227 kHz sub channels16643.6
G.722.1Coding for low frame loss systems1624/32n/a
G.723.1Dual rate speech coder85.3/6.33.8
G.726Adaptive Differential Pulse Code Modulation (ADPCM)816/24/32/404.3
G.729Conjugate-Structure Algebraic-Code-Excited Linear-Prediction (CS-ACELP)884.02
GSMGlobal System for Mobile communications8132.5
iLBCinternet Low Bitrate Codec813.33.7
LPC-10Linear-Predictive Codec82.42.3
SpeexMultivairable rate, with Narrow and Wide band operation8/16/322.15-24.6 (Narrow Band), 4-44.2 (Wide Band)n/a
This table lists well known codecs used to compress/decompress human speech signals. Sampling rate shows the range of sound frequencies sampled; the bit rate determines the quality of the sound reproduced by the codec, where a higher bit rate allows for better sound quality to be transmitted, bearing in mind a high bit rate will utilise more bandwidth. The Mean Opinion Score (MOS) is a numerical measure (a rating out of 5) of the quality of speech at the receiving end of a phone line.

Source: Symbio Networks














 

 

 

 

 




 

What sort of broadband do I need?

The broadband connection is quite important. The minimum required for VoIP is ideally 256Kbps download. Users can get away with 128/64Kbps, but the bigger the pipes at home the better the VoIP service as it reduces the chance of voice traffic having to compete with other (larger) data files such as MP3 or images. Typically, a VoIP call will consume about 20Kbps of bandwidth. So if a user has a 128/64Kbps service, the call will use about 15 per cent download and about 30 per cent of the upload bandwidth available.

But speed is not the only thing that matters. The actual broadband service is also critically important. Ultimately, a VoIP service is totally dependent on a reliable broadband service provider to help deliver voice traffic. If a user's ADSL/cable/wireless broadband service provider has continual dropouts or outages, it will obviously affect the VoIP service. You cannot surf the Internet and open e-mails when there are outages. Nor can you make VoIP calls.

It is worth noting that although users are doing away with their telephone provider if they chose to use a VoIP service, they are still required to pay the telephone line rental for the ADSL-enabled phone line. This is because ADSL is an add-on service for telephone subscribers. If users are on cable, they would be subject to the cable provider's subscription rates.

What is a VoIP service provider?

A service provider offers the connection to other VoIP services or to the PSTN. In other words, they are responsible for directing your call to where it is supposed to go.

As with any other type of service provider, VoIP service levels will differ. Most service providers charge a monthly fee, then additional costs when calls are made. Service providers offer different rates based on their services. Charges to look out for are local call rates, STD rates, mobile rates, and rates to any international destinations that may be of interest to the consumer. These prices are charged by the minute and are continually negotiated by the service provider, other VoIP providers and telcos around the world. As a result, call prices can change rapidly, so it is important to keep an eye on the cost of your calls.

Users should note that there are differences between public and private numbering schemes.

If the user only wants to make cheap outgoing calls, and receive calls within the service provider's own network, then a private number is sufficient.

Some services also enable users to receive calls from regular telephones -- at no extra cost. This feature is known as DID (Direct Inward Dialling) and, although you can't use your existing number for the moment, you can get a real, regular eight-digit format number for people to call.

 
Next >